Your Cart is Empty
It often starts gradually.
Perhaps your hip aches after a long walk. Then you notice it's harder to put on your socks. Getting out of the car becomes uncomfortable. You stop taking the stairs when there's an elevator nearby. Eventually, you find yourself planning your day around what your hip will—and won't—allow you to do.
At some point, an inevitable question arises:
Is it time for a hip replacement?
It's a question millions of people with hip arthritis eventually face. But contrary to what you might expect, there isn't a particular X-ray finding, pain score or age that automatically means it's time for surgery.
The decision is much more personal.
First, Is the Pain Actually Coming From Your Hip?
One of the confusing things about hip problems is that the location of the pain isn't always where people expect it to be.
Pain caused by osteoarthritis of the hip is frequently felt in the groin or front of the thigh, although it can also occur around the side of the hip, buttock or even travel toward the knee.
Meanwhile, pain around the outside of the hip may originate from tendons or a condition known as greater trochanteric pain syndrome. Pain coming from the lower back can also radiate into the buttock and hip area.
That's why persistent hip pain deserves a proper assessment. Before discussing replacement surgery, your healthcare provider needs to determine whether the hip joint itself is actually the problem.
What Happens in Hip Osteoarthritis?
The hip is a ball-and-socket joint. The rounded head of the thigh bone fits into a socket in the pelvis, with cartilage helping the surfaces glide smoothly over one another.
With osteoarthritis, the entire joint gradually changes. Cartilage deteriorates, the underlying bone changes, and inflammation can develop within and around the joint. As arthritis progresses, the joint may become increasingly stiff and painful.
Age is a major risk factor, but osteoarthritis isn't simply the inevitable result of getting older. Previous injuries, genetics, body weight and the shape and structure of the hip can all influence someone's risk.
Keep in mind that an X-ray doesn't tell the whole story. Some people have substantial arthritis visible on an X-ray but surprisingly no, or almost no symptoms. Others experience significant pain and disability.
Doctors therefore don't replace hips simply because an X-ray looks bad. They treat the person—not the picture.
What Should You Try Before Surgery?
For many people, treatment begins conservatively.
Exercise is particularly important. Strengthening the muscles around the hips and legs can help support the joint, while maintaining mobility helps prevent further loss of function.
Marine collagen can bring significant relief to people suffering for all types of osteoarthritis. It can help rejuvenate the soft tissues and also significantly reduce inflammation and improve mobility.
Low-impact activities such as walking, cycling, swimming and water exercise may be easier to tolerate than higher-impact activities.
Physiotherapy can help identify exercises appropriate for your particular limitations and can sometimes improve mobility considerably.
Weight management can also make a difference for people who are overweight. The hip is a major weight-bearing joint, and reducing excess body weight can decrease the load placed upon it.
Pain medications and anti-inflammatory drugs may provide relief for some people, although these medications aren't appropriate for everyone—particularly with long-term use. Your healthcare provider or pharmacist can help determine what is safe based on your health and other medications.
But eventually, conservative treatments may stop providing enough relief. That's when the conversation about hip replacement becomes more serious.
So, How Do You Know When It's Time?
Rather than asking simply “How much does my hip hurt?”, it can be more useful to ask: “How much is my hip changing the way I live?”
That distinction matters.
Perhaps you've stopped walking with friends because you can't keep up. Maybe you've given up gardening, golf or travelling. Perhaps grocery shopping has become an ordeal, you're struggling with stairs, or you can no longer comfortably put on shoes and socks.
Sleep is another important consideration. Hip arthritis that regularly wakes you at night or prevents you from finding a comfortable sleeping position can have a significant effect on your overall quality of life.
You may also find that the distance you can comfortably walk keeps shrinking. These functional changes can be more meaningful than a number on a pain scale.
Don't Wait Until You Can Barely Walk
Some people believe they should postpone joint replacement for as long as humanly possible.
There are sensible reasons not to rush into surgery. Hip replacement is a major operation and, like any surgery, carries risks including infection, blood clots, dislocation and complications associated with anesthesia.
Artificial joints also don't last forever, which can be an important consideration for younger patients. But waiting indefinitely has disadvantages too.
If pain causes you to become increasingly inactive, muscles can weaken and overall fitness can decline. You may gain weight, lose mobility and become less confident walking. In some people, prolonged inactivity can affect independence and general health.
The objective isn't to earn your way into surgery by tolerating as much pain as possible.
It's to find the point at which the expected improvement in your quality of life outweighs the risks and disadvantages of the operation.
What Actually Happens During a Hip Replacement?
Despite the name, surgeons don't replace your entire hip.
During a total hip replacement, the damaged ball at the top of the thigh bone is removed and replaced with an artificial component. The damaged surface of the socket is also replaced. Together, these components create a new joint surface.
Hip replacement has become one of the most successful procedures in orthopedic surgery. For appropriately selected patients with advanced hip arthritis, it can dramatically reduce pain and improve mobility and quality of life.
Recovery, however, isn't instantaneous.
Most people are encouraged to begin standing and walking quite soon after surgery, but regaining strength, endurance and confidence takes time. Recovery continues over weeks and months, and individual experiences vary. Be patient and commit to the exercises.
Age Isn't the Deciding Factor
People sometimes assume they're either too young or too old for hip replacement. Neither is necessarily true.
Surgeons consider overall health, severity of arthritis, symptoms, activity level and expected benefit—not simply the date on your birth certificate.
An active person in their 60s whose life has become severely restricted by hip arthritis may have a compelling reason for surgery. An older adult in otherwise reasonable health may also be an excellent candidate.
Conversely, someone with severe-looking arthritis on an X-ray but relatively little pain and good function may have no reason to rush into an operation.
The Question Worth Asking Yourself
If you're wondering whether you're approaching the point of hip replacement, try thinking about what your life looked like a year or two ago. What have you stopped doing?
Can you still walk the distances you want to walk? Can you travel comfortably? Exercise? Climb stairs? Sleep through the night? Get dressed without struggling? Participate in the activities that matter to you?
Most importantly, are nonsurgical treatments still allowing you to live reasonably well?
If the answers are increasingly "no," it may be time for a conversation with your doctor about seeing an orthopedic surgeon.
That doesn't commit you to surgery. It simply allows you to understand your options.
There is no magic moment when a painful hip officially becomes ready for replacement.
The decision usually comes from a combination of significant arthritis, persistent pain, declining mobility and an increasing loss of the activities that make everyday life enjoyable, despite appropriate nonsurgical treatment.
But neither should someone spend years progressively shrinking their life because they believe they haven't suffered enough to justify surgery.
Sometimes the most important question isn't “Can I tolerate this pain a little longer?”
It's “How much of my life am I giving up because of my hip?”
